Who is Online

We have 66 guests and no members online

Destruction

Despite the Flak towers, and the residual Luftwaffe, Berlin was blasted.  British bombers dropped 45,517 tons of bombs then the Americans dropped a further 23,000 tons. 

The head of British Bomber Command, Air Vice Marshall 'Bomber' Harris was convinced, despite evidence to the contrary in London, that the morale of civilians was destroyed when their city was attacked and as a result they would put pressure on their government to capitulate. 

While Churchill may have had doubts he supported Harris saying: “We need to make the enemy burn and bleed in every way.”  In addition he knew that it was good for British morale to bomb German cities in retaliation for London, in what became known as 'feel good raids'.  See the above link to  'Bomber' Harris

Eventually it was realised that the strategy of bombing civilians, if done to excess, hardens their resolve to fight back.  We have a modern example in the Gaza Strip.  But this was not before raids on Germany killed over 600,000 German civilians and seriously damaged 6 million homes and a halt was finally called to the slaughter. Then came Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

The final wave of destruction in Berlin came ahead of the invading Russian army when, during street to street fighting, the Russians used artillery and tanks to destroy entire buildings that harboured a Hitler Youth offering token resistance.

 

Berlin in 1945 - Mainly in the British Sector - Märkisches Museum

 

One obvious moral of the story is that, contrary to Hitler's contention, attack is not the best means of defence.  Sitting around a table is.  In particular, don't attack someone who might have the means to fight back; or big friends. 

It's arguable that this bombing constituted a war crime.  But putting that aside, by concentrating bombing on civilian targets a large number of economically strategic targets like transport and electricity infrastructure remained either undamaged or in a state that could be quickly repaired.  Those of you familiar with Joseph Heller's Catch 22 will recognise a theme.

For example, about 50 km north-east of Berlin is the strategic Schiffshebewerk (ship lift) on the Oder-Havel canal system. This canal was and is used to move heavy machinery and materials between Germany and Poland, at that time for the assault on the Baltic States and then on the Soviet Union. 

Compared with the thousands of tons of bombs committed to killing civilians in nearby Berlin, the bombing raids were token and obviously inadequate to destroy it, because unlike many hospitals and schools in Berlin there it still stands, unscathed.  

 

Schiffshebewerk Niederfinow lowering a barge-load of heavy parts - an obvious strategic target but largely unharmed.
It was built contemporaneously with the Sydney Harbour Bridge and the Empire State building
and uses the same technology - hot riveted, rolled steel trusses.
Steel rolling technology owes its development to rail rolling near Newcastle-on-Tyne see the McKie Family
The new one being built nearby uses the technology of the late 20th century - ferroconcrete.

 

If you think failing to disrupt strategic transport to Poland was of little moment consider that between 1940 and the defeat of the Third Reich in 1945 the Nazis would attempt to solve 'the Jewish problem' (whatever that was) and put to death over a million Jews in the gas chambers of Auschwitz in Poland. 

To the north of Berlin, not far from the Schiffshebewerk, is the Sachsenhausen concentration camp that is almost as chilling as Auschwitz, particularly as it was subsequently used by the Russians as NKVD special camp Nr. 7.  So the abuses here carried on during post-war Stalinist purges.

 

Sachsenhausen Concentration Camp
There is a longer discussion of concentration camps on this website - follow this link
WARNING this content is distressing.

 

As I've said repeatedly on this website none of us born after 1940 would have been conceived had any of these players done anything different.  Obviously that extends to our children and grandchildren and to those yet to be born.   What's done is done and it had to be so for the now to be now.  But we should take heed and learn from the horrors as well as the achievements of the past.

In particular, it would be nice if we could put religious and political zealotry behind us.  Follow this link to The Meaning of Life - my message to my children and now grandchildren on the subject of religious fundamentalism. 

 

 

No comments

Travel

Bridge over the River Kwai

 

 

In 1957-58 the film ‘The Bridge on the River Kwai‘ was ground breaking.  It was remarkable for being mainly shot on location (in Ceylon not Thailand) rather than in a studio and for involving the construction and demolition of a real, fully functioning rail bridge.   It's still regarded by many as one of the finest movies ever made. 

One of the things a tourist to Bangkok is encouraged to do is to take a day trip to the actual bridge.

Read more: Bridge over the River Kwai

Fiction, Recollections & News

The U-2 Incident

 

 

 

In 1960 the Russians shot down an American U-2 spy plane that was overflying and photographing their military bases.  The U-2 Incident was big news when I was in High School and I remember it quite clearly. 

The Incident forms the background to Bridge of Spies a 2015 movie, directed by Steven Spielberg and starring Tom Hanks and Mark Rylance from a screenplay written by Matt Charman together with Ethan and Joel Coen that centres on these true events. 

Spielberg and the Cohen Brothers.  Who could miss it?

 

 

Read more: The U-2 Incident

Opinions and Philosophy

Science, Magic and Religion

 

(UCLA History 2D Lectures 1 & 2)

 

Professor Courtenay Raia lectures on science and religion as historical phenomena that have evolved over time; starting in pre-history. She goes on to examine the pre-1700 mind-set when science encompassed elements of magic; how Western cosmologies became 'disenchanted'; and how magical traditions have been transformed into modern mysticisms.

The lectures raise a lot of interesting issues.  For example in Lecture 1, dealing with pre-history, it is convincingly argued that 'The Secret', promoted by Oprah, is not a secret at all, but is the natural primitive human belief position: that it is fundamentally an appeal to magic; the primitive 'default' position. 

But magic is suppressed by both religion and science.  So in our modern secular culture traditional magic has itself been transmogrified, magically transformed, into mysticism.

Read more: Science, Magic and Religion

Terms of Use

Terms of Use                                                                    Copyright